Thursday, March 8, 2012

The Real Scholar Finds the Third Side

“Every story has two sides, but the real scholar finds the third side” – Dad

My dad always says this to me, and I have never considered him to be more right than I do now. With the recent uproar of the Kony 2012 campaign in the last few days, I feel that this is the best time to reflect upon this quote. I learned about Invisible Children in grade 11, when my social studies teacher screened their first video in class. At the time I wasn’t educated enough on the subject, the Invisible Children organization, or their campaign, and therefore my perspective was a bit shallow. This time, I am better able to form a sophisticated opinion.

Kony 2012 advocates for bringing the Ugandan warlord to justice through raising awareness in the western world by the means of social media. The video is an excellent example of how social media campaigns have the potential to be extremely successful if used correctly. The video did a brilliant job of touching on people’s emotions through strong images, and advanced editing skills; it thus went viral Tuesday night with about 2.7 million hits (source: taken from Youtube Tuesday evening)!

I admire individuals who want to get involved with the movement, however I encourage everyone interested in Kony 2012 to ask questions and be critical; do not allow yourself to be brainwashed by a sole video you saw online, but rather use that information to discover a second side of the story! The media exposes only what they want you to see, but it is up to you to ask questions and dig deeper; never be satisfied with information at face-value. With regards to  Kony 2012, I believe the story is deeper than what Jason Russell has portrayed in his video. First of all, the issue of child soldiers is rather delicate and extremely complex. According to Radio Free Europe, approximately “300, 000 children are currently involved in 33 armed conflicts around the world” including areas such as El Salvador, Ethiopia, and Afghanistan. Yes, Joseph Kony is doing horrible things, but he is definitely not the only one involved in atrocities – I encourage you all to do some research on the issue of child soldiers and learn the global context of it. If you are truly for the cause, you will go beyond the Kony 2012 campaign and educate yourself about the world issue of child soldiers.

Another article I came across suggests that the Invisible Children Organization supports direct military intervention and the money they raise goes towards the Ugandan government’s army and other military forces of the sort. These armies are known for and have been accused of looting, rape, and other atrocities similar to ones accused of Kony.  Aside from that, is supporting the military the best way to solve this problem? Should we, as North Americans, even be attempting to take matters in our own hands or rather be helping those at risk help themselves? This ties into the term “White Man’s Burden” – if you do not know what this is, do some research! The article also suggests that in the previous year, $8, 676, 613 was spent by the organization and only 32% of that went to direct services. Most of Invisible Children’s funding goes towards raising awareness rather than contributing to the actual cause, however the organization is known to exaggerate and manipulate facts. This is an example of media showing you what they want you to see. It has been said that Kony has been inactive in Uganda since 2006...so why the sudden uproar? I definitely want to do more research about these stats and claims against Invisible Children to paint a clearer picture of what is going on with the organization. 

Well I’ve rambled on for quite some time now, so I just want to end this post by saying that educating yourself on an issue is extremely powerful. Don’t ever accept what the media hands you without doing your own research; who knows, you may find the third side of the story!

-Madiha

8 comments:

  1. always an interesting read :) good job!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Good read! It is very essential to look at the Big Picture and both sides of a story to avoid a Clash of Ignorance. Justin Trudeau retweeted Bob Rae yesterday saying "Kony video good but out of date - he's left Uganda, many LRA members have signed ceasefire - he's in Congo, UN and African Union involved" He went on to further state "Those affected by "Kony virus" need to take their passion and channel to what is happening in the region now - Canadian engagement needed"

    ReplyDelete
  3. Madiha - You read my mind! I watched this video yesterday and had some of the same feelings you do. I think it's great that so many people are supporting a singular cause but I feel like too many people are taking everything they see at face value. Yes, stopping and trying Kony in court for war crimes would be great, but the problem is much deeper than that.

    Kony may be the leader that is in charge of the LRA operation of using child soldiers, but stopping him doesn't necessarily stop the cycle. And many people are misunderstanding this fact.

    On a side note, I also read the visiblechildren blog post and as a result of that Invisible Children posted a response. The response can be found here:
    http://s3.amazonaws.com/www.invisiblechildren.com/critiques.html

    You are amazing Madiha!! :)

    ReplyDelete
  4. Very well written Madiha! I myself like you saw the Invisible Children documentary sometime in high school but never went in depth or cared too much about it. But after watching the video KONY 2012, I was determined to stop Kony and help the kids in whatever way possible. As I was watching it I had similar concerns as you did and I am still debating and arguing if putting up posters and banners on April 20th is going to make a difference. I have been doing research myself and after looking at a few legitimate sources such as Interpol, FBI and Forbes, I found that KONY is not even on the top 5 Most Wanted criminals anymore. He has lost his power and is not that active anymore. So that makes me question if stopping Kony is the number one priority of the youth of the world. Maybe not.

    But regardless I do admire the efforts of Jason Russell and I still think Kony should be stopped as soon as possible. The video also did not touch on the details and we still don't know Kony's motives for doing all this, so maybe we should also research that. But overall the KONY 2012 was one of the best documentaries I have seen, it was very well made and they touched the lives of every single individual who has seen it.

    "A country’s standing in our contemporary world is no longer recognised by what it can achieve for itself, but by what it can do for others." - H.H Aga Khan

    (KONY 2012 is a great example of exactly what H.H talks about)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I always love your comments! Yes the documentary was done very well and harnessed social media to its fullest potential! I think it is a great starting point for research! I admire Jason Russell for starting this movement because so many Westerners came out of their bubble and became involved with a world issue! A friend of mine wasn't even aware of some of the most intricate conflicts going on around the globe, but she started becoming interested after the Kony campaign and is learning about the Palestinian- Israeli conflict now! I would love to see everyone interested in Kony 2012 go beyond the campaign and educate themselves about what's going on in the world. Education is such a powerful tool, and I firmly believe it is when the human race starts asking questions and criticizing, that some of the most complex problems can be solved!

      so glad you liked it Moin :)

      Delete
  5. Always worth reading Madiha!

    KONY 2012 has exploded the past couple of days and it definitely needs to be addressed.

    Have you read IC's response to critics? What are your thoughts?

    ReplyDelete
  6. Well done darling :). You raised some good points and brought a lot of interesting issues to light. On a different note, your dad is a genius! What a great quote to live by...

    ReplyDelete
  7. I love your response once again:)!
    I really agree with the fact that this group really used social media very well to get their video all over the place. Very smart tactic indeed. However in terms of the addressing the issue, I agree that there are more than one side to this story. And after reading a few articles to follow up on this issue, I agree there is way more involved than what they portrayed.
    I love the quote your dad said, because it is very true to everything in life, especially with the issue about Kony and the Ugandan affairs.
    Really enjoyed this post:)
    Keep them coming!!

    ReplyDelete